Incomplete dominance vs codominance
Both break the simple dominant-recessive rule, and both turn 3:1 into 1:2:1. The difference is what the heterozygote looks like: a blend, or both at once.
With complete dominance, one allele masks the other. A heterozygote (Aa) looks exactly like a homozygous dominant (AA), which is why crossing two heterozygotes gives the familiar 3:1 ratio. But plenty of genes don't work that way. In those, the heterozygote has its own phenotype, and there are two ways that can happen.
| Incomplete dominance | Codominance | |
|---|---|---|
| Heterozygote shows | An intermediate blend of the two | Both parental traits, fully and at once |
| Classic example | Red × white snapdragons → pink | IAIB → blood type AB |
| Other examples | Four o'clock flowers; wavy hair from curly × straight (simplified) | Roan cattle (red and white hairs mixed); MN blood group |
| Heterozygote cross ratio | 1 : 2 : 1 | 1 : 2 : 1 |
| Quick test | Could you mix the parents' traits to get it, like paint? | Can you still see each parent's trait separately? |
Incomplete dominance: the blend
In snapdragons, one flower color allele (call it R) makes red pigment and the other (r) makes none. An RR plant has two working copies and is red. An rr plant is white. An Rr plant has only one working copy, makes about half the pigment, and is pink. Neither allele is dominant. The pink is a genuine in-between.
| R | r | |
|---|---|---|
| R | RR | Rr |
| r | Rr | rr |
Pink × pink (Rr × Rr) gives 1 red : 2 pink : 1 white.
The Punnett square is drawn exactly as usual. Only the reading changes: Rr no longer counts as red, so the phenotype ratio is 1:2:1, the same as the genotype ratio. A useful consequence: under incomplete dominance you can read every plant's genotype straight from its color.
Incomplete dominance also shows why "blending inheritance" was wrong. Pink parents don't produce only pink children. A quarter of their offspring are red and a quarter white, because the R and r alleles were never blended. They were only expressed together. This was exactly Mendel's point.
A note on notation. Textbooks write incompletely dominant alleles in several ways: R and r, CR and CW, or R and R′. They all mean the same thing. Uppercase/lowercase is the common shorthand, but it doesn't imply dominance here.
Codominance: both at once
The ABO blood group is the standard example. The IA allele puts the A antigen on red blood cells and IB puts the B antigen. Someone with IAIB doesn't get a halfway antigen. They get both, fully, and are type AB. Roan cattle are another: a red × white cross gives calves with red hairs and white hairs mixed together, not pink hair.
| IA | IB | |
|---|---|---|
| IA | IAIA | IAIB |
| IB | IAIB | IBIB |
AB × AB (IAIB × IAIB) gives 1 A : 2 AB : 1 B.
Same 1:2:1 ratio, different biology. The ABO gene also has a third allele, i, which makes no antigen. Both IA and IB are completely dominant over i. So one gene can show codominance between two alleles and complete dominance over a third. That's why a type A parent can be IAIA or IAi, and why two type A parents can have a type O child.
Telling them apart in a question
Read the description of the heterozygote:
- Words like pink, intermediate, medium, wavy, in between mean incomplete dominance.
- Words like both, spotted, speckled, roan, mixed hairs, AB mean codominance.
- If the heterozygote looks like one of the parents, it's ordinary complete dominance after all.
For calculations it often doesn't matter which it is. Either way you draw a normal Punnett square and treat the heterozygote as a third phenotype. The label only matters when a question asks you to name the pattern.
Dominance is about phenotype, not alleles
One subtlety tends to come up in advanced courses: whether an allele looks dominant depends on which phenotype you measure. Take the sickle-cell allele. Carriers usually have no symptoms, so for the disease it behaves as recessive. Look at the hemoglobin molecules themselves and carriers make both normal and sickle hemoglobin: codominance. Measure how easily red cells sickle at low oxygen and carriers fall in between: incomplete dominance. Same alleles, three answers, depending on what you look at.
Practice both
Level 2 problems include snapdragon crosses and ABO blood types, with the Punnett square shown after every answer.
Practice nowThe Punnett square calculator lets you set each gene to complete dominance, incomplete dominance or codominance, and has a separate mode for ABO blood types.